Addiction Support
  • Home
  • I am Recovering
    • Addiction
    • Addiction & Recovery
    • Recovery Testimonies
    • Job Search Guide
    • Self Employment
  • Support
    • Support for addiction
    • Meeting List of NA in India
    • Meeting List of AA in India
    • Counseling
  • Help & Information
    • Where To Find Help
    • Prevention and Management
  • Awareness
    • For Those Concerned
  • Listen
    • Voices from the Field
  • Law
    • Drugs & Law
  • Features
  • Resources
  • FAQ
    • FAQs on Alcohol
    • FAQs on HIV/AIDS
    • FAQs on Drugs
    • FAQs for Parents
    • FAQs on Recovery
  • Showcasing Initiatives
    • Kripa Foundation
    • Muktangan De-addiction
    • World No Tobacco Day
    • Renaissance Therapy Center
Aarogya.com
Marathi | Gujarati | Register | Login
  • Home
  • News and Update
  • News Year 2010
  • Will Conservative plans to overhaul heroin addiction treatment work? - The Guardian

News and Update

Will Conservative plans to overhaul heroin addiction treatment work? - The Guardian

  • Print
  • Email
Details
Hits: 2197
Methadone

A member of the public takes his prescription of methadone at a Houlihan pharmacy in Glasgow. Photograph: Danny Lawson/PA Archive/PA Photos

The policy of giving problematic drug users the heroin substitute methadone – a cornerstone of official efforts to cut the huge amount of crime linked to illicit substance misuse – is being criticised as a waste of money that does little to wean people off drugs and leaves too many of those receiving regular doses of the green liquid living "half-lives".

The fact that David Cameron, during last week's televised party leaders' debate, voiced his concern that too many problem drug users do not manage to shake off their addiction shows that the issue has attracted attention in high places.

A coalition of opponents of methadone maintenance includes the Centre for Policy Studies rightwing thinktank, leading drugs researcher Neil McKeganey and, most ominously for the vast majority of workers in the drugs field who are pro-methadone, many senior figures in the Conservative party.

There are an estimated 330,000 people in England alone who are addicted to heroin, crack cocaine, or both. They are extremely challenging, cost the country an estimated £15bn a year, and commit an estimated £13.9bn of crime annually. A record 200,000 of those 330,000 are in treatment, which usually involves methadone. Drug treatment has expanded in recent years, with around 11,000 drugs workers in England and at least 1,000 drug projects across the UK, variously funded by the NHS, councils, the police, charities or combinations of some of them. Some £800m a year is spent on drug treatment, half of it by the NHS's National Treatment Agency for Substance Misuse.

The Tories want an overhaul of the system, with many more people going into residential rehabilitation and making a serious effort to become drug-free, and fewer being given methadone.

"Methadone maintenance is under the spotlight," says Martin Barnes, chief executive of DrugScope, which represents about 700 local drugs agencies. "There had been differences of opinion in the field for a while because some people weren't comfortable with methadone maintenance."

Their case has been bolstered by the cross-party public accounts committee, which two weeks ago issued a highly-critical report, called Tackling Problem Drug Use. It said that just 15,000 of 165,000 problem drug users who underwent community-based treatment last year emerged free of dependence. In addition, it said it was "unacceptable" that the Home Office had not properly evaluated whether key elements of its £1.2bn-a-year strategy to tackle drugs misuse in England actually worked, and did not know if that strategy directly reduced the huge cost of crime committed by addicts.

"The department [Home Office] does not know how to most effectively tackle problem drug use," the MPs said, before adding that "residential rehabilitation may be effective for those who have failed to 'go clean' in other forms of treatment". That is what the Tories want more of..

The gathering storm over methadone began in late 2006, when former Tory leader Iain Duncan Smith's Centre for Social Justice thinktank published its Breakdown Britain report.

Partly informed by Duncan Smith's scathing critique of methadone, the Tories have in the last two years attacked the reliance on methadone to treat large numbers of addicts as "failed" and "wrong". Shadow justice secretary Dominic Grieve, for example, has claimed: "The government's approach of trying to 'manage' addiction is an admission of failure."

David Burrowes, a shadow spokesman on criminal justice, is one of the Tories who have been consistently questioning the cost and efficacy of methadone treatment, both in the community and in prisons. "It's not for me to cast moral judgments about whether methadone is wrong or right," says Burrowes, a former criminal solicitor whose interest in drugs policy developed from seeing clients with chaotic or ruined lives fail to kick drugs. "We need to look at outcomes, and the outcomes are just not good enough.

"The public expect that addicts have to get off their drugs, but too many end up parked up on methadone. They become dependent on it and end up not being able to contribute to their families or society. I've seen too many individuals on methadone who are living half-lives, and that's not good enough." Burrowes also claims that it does not cut crime – the main justification for the policy.

The Tories want much more effort put into getting drug-using offenders to go clean – what they call "recovery" – and their manifesto proposes abstinence-based drug rehabilitation orders. But some say that is a simplistic response to the complex problem of opiate dependency. Defenders of methadone point out that the policy was introduced by the previous Tory government as a vital harm-reduction measure.

Roy Robertson, an Edinburgh GP and ex-member of the Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs, is dubious that abstinence will work for many users. "Most governments have endorsed methadone treatment, not because they liked the implications that drugs are only controlled by this palliative method, but because there are few alternatives," he says.

Barnes argues that every drugs worker wants their clients to get clean, and the "maintenance v recovery" debate is a polarised argument that doesn't help anybody. "The evidence is that methadone is a very effective treatment for helping many people out of their chaos, such as cutting crime," he says. "It stabilises people and helps them re-establish relations with their family."

DrugScope is calling for a balanced treatment system tailored to the needs of the client, incorporating both maintenance and abstinence options.

It is hard to predict what a change of policy under the Tories would mean. While some addicts would accept a place in an abstinence-based rehabilitation centre, many would not. "If there's a shift away from methadone, and spending on services offering maintenance [through methadone] is cut, the danger is that drug users might vote with their feet and drop out of treatment or not come forward in the first place," Barnes warns. "It's a major attraction for heroin users going into treatment that they'll be offered a methadone script."



Disclaimer: The news story on this page is the copyright of the cited publication. This has been reproduced here for visitors to review, comment on and discuss. This is in keeping with the principle of ‘Fair dealing’ or ‘Fair use’. Visitors may click on the publication name, in the news story, to visit the original article as it appears on the publication’s website.

News and Update

  • Good Counsellors Transform Addicts’ Lives
  • Think Before You Drink
  • Stop Using Tobacco Products, Betel Nut
  • Second-Hand Smoking Kills 6L People Annually: WHO Study
  • India Ranks A Lowly 100 In Campaign Against Tobacco
  • High Spirits Drive Them Into Danger Zone
  • City Getting High On Cocaine
  • Drunk Driving Can Cost You as Much as 6,000
  • Binge Drinking Makes Men Impulsive
  • Passive Smokers Suffer For no Fault Of Theirs, Enforce Ban: HC
  • Women Smokers Have High Risk Of Getting Brain Stroke
  • Smoking Doubles Risk Of Dementia
  • Kerala To Consider Using Liquor Revenue To Help Alcohol Victims
  • Chain Smoker Or A Controlled One? It's In Your DNA
  • Now, State Gets High On Ganja Chocolates
  • Why Not Ban Gutka Sachets, SC Asks Centre
  • 29 Per Cent Indians Exposed To Second-hand Smoke Outside Home
  • ‘Average Age Of Tobacco Users 17.8 Years’
  • 275 Million Hooked To Tobacco: Survey
  • Teens In High Spirits
  • Alcohol Intake Among Teens On The Rise
  • Stiff Fines In New Excise Act
  • One Of Every 100 Patnaites A Drug Addict
  • 25% Of Liver Failures Occur Due To Alcohol Consumption
  • Harm-reduction strategies proving successful
  • Smoking Ban Goes Up In Smoke
  • Helping E-addicts Sign Out
  • In Gujarat Bank, A Higher Loan Rate For Tobacco Addicts
  • ‘Youngsters Prefer Chewing Tobacco To Taking A Puff’
  • Cancer Patients Want More ‘Realistic’ Warnings On Tobacco Packets
  • Nine-Member Drug Peddler Gang Nabbed
  • Punjab Bans Sale Of Tobacco Products Near Schools
  • Anti-liquor Movement Has No Takers In Urban Areas
  • A GenX Fighter Against Addiction
  • Drug Peddler In Police Net
  • Rape Victims Taken For De-addiction
  • Say No To That First Puff: Doctors To Bring Out Short Film To Educate Teenagers
  • Smoking Can Lead To Spinal Disorders Too
  • Drug That Helps Prevent Relapse In Alcoholics Effectively
  • Postman Among 4 Held For Smuggling Ganja Through Parcels
  • City Turning Into Transit Point For Drug Smuggling
  • Heroin Worth Rs 4cr Seized In Dadri, 4 Held
  • How Drug Abuse Robs Lasting Pleasures
  • Narcotics Gang Busted, Rs 10L Worth Heroin Seized
  • High On Haze: Drugs And The City Campaigns, Impotency Fear Drive Youth Away From Gutkha
  • Sale Of Liquor Has Doubled In Two Years
  • De-addiction: Women Recover Faster Than Men
  • Drug Trade Shows No Signs Of Abating
  • Average age of addicts 34, down 4 in 2 yrs: Muktangan sources
  • `Eyeing Revenue, Govt Helping Alcoholism'
  • Alcoholics: Age Bracket Dips, With Money To Burn
  • Pakistani Among 3 Held With Heroin Worth Rs 10 Crore
  • City A Safe Haven For Drug Peddlers
  • Customs Man, 6 Others Held For Selling Heroin
  • Muktangan Centre Celebrates Silver Jubilee
  • 'Liquor Policy Promotes Addiction'
  • Hearing Impaired Band Strikes Right Chord
  • International Drug Cartel Busted, 8 Foreigners Held
  • Giving Up Smoking Ups Sex Life
  • Big Catch
  • ‘Beer Raises Risk Of Skin Disease In Women By 70%'
  • New Study Shows Fourfold Increase In Substance Abuse Treatment Admissions Involving Non-Medical Use of Prescription Narcotic Pain Relievers In Ten Year Period (1998-2008)
  • Excessive Drinking Can Cause Osteoporosis, Says Expert
  • Film Producer In The Dock
  • Hooked to Hookah?
  • Kick the stick!
  • Tollywood Hooked To Heady ‘stuff’
  • Narcotics Cell Nabs 4, Seizes 272 kg Ganja
  • Heroin Worth Rs 25 cr Seized From Car
  • Smoking ‘Influences Gene Function’
  • Desperate Addicts In Africa Inject Other’s Blood
  • Fatal Addiction
  • Mums’ Booze Binges Cause Disorders In Kids
  • African Drug Peddlers Held
  • Ladakhis Cancel Music Fest Over Alcohol Fears
  • Cancer Catches Them Young
  • Seeing Movies Increases Tobacco Intake
  • Two Nigerians in the Net for Selling Drugs
  • ‘Bail Ok For Carrying Small Drugs Cache’
  • Socking Story In City Temples
  • Illicit Drugs Get a Kick from 'Jhatka'
  • Punjab to Set Up 20 More De-Addiction Centres
  • Internet Addiction, Feel Experts, can Cause People to Become More Impulsive, Impatient and Even Narcissistic
  • India Plans New Policy To Stop Drug Abuse
  • Love Life, Not Drugs: Awachat's Message to the Youth
  • Awareness Camp Held to Mark International Drug Abuse Day
  • Drug Trade: State a Major Transit Point
  • International Day Against Drug Abuse
  • Hide And Go Seek!
  • Try Deaddiction, it Works
  • After 7-yr 'Fun', this Addict Found a Way Out
  • Parenting Style Can Prevent Heavy Drinking
  • Most Women Drug Abusers Below 20 Years
  • Smoking And Alcohol Intake To Blame For Absenteeism
  • Puberty Linked To Sleep Disorders, Alcohol Abuse
  • Govt In A Spot Over Tobacco Meeting
  • Cops Step Up Action Against Drunk Drivers
  • Draft De-addiction Policy To Be Announced Soon
  • 'Alcoholics Are Not Most Deserving For Diver Transplant'
  • Bhutan to Ban Tobacco Sale Again
  • Quitting Smoking Before Pregnancy Could Save Babies Lives
  • Post Accident, 3-Year-Old Takes To Smoking, Drinking
  • Hookah Smoking Not So Harmful? Wrong
  • Three Drug Cartels Busted, Charas Worth Rs 1cr Seized
  • Alcohol Use, Smoking, Coffee Drinking, Linked To Migraines In Teens
  • At 75, Alcoholics Anonymous Plans Poster Exhibition, Meetings
  • Liquor-hit Bank On Aphrodisiac Boost
  • Supervised Use Of Heroin Keeps Addicts Clean
  • No Smoking Zones? Study Finds High Nicotine Levels In Schools, Hospitals
  • Beware! Smoker's Kiss Can Be Deadly
  • Not Passive Air Nicotine Monitor To Gauge What Smokers Leave Behind
  • Police Crack Down On Tobacco Sellers
  • '8% Girls Under 15 Consume Tobacco'
  • Survey Takes Stock Of Docs Who Smoke
  • Read The Smoke Signals
  • New De-Addiction Programme
  • Plans Go up In Smoke
  • Tobacco Addiction Ruins Sex Life: experts
  • $5 Million Grant for Tobacco Control Programme
  • 'No Tobacco Day' at Ahmedabad Medical Association
  • Former Addicts Advocate Self-Control, Firm Faith
  • More People Willing to Stub the Stick: Docs
  • Kids, Adolescents take to Tobacco
  • Women Smokers Gamble with Life
  • Surge in Women Smokers a Cause for Worry for Medical Fraternity
  • World No Tobacco Day Focusing on Women Smokers
  • Study Triggers Smoke Alarm for BPOs
  • A Dubious High for 'Spirited' Women in India's Cities
  • Nation's Health at Risk from Cheap Alcohol
  • Anti-Tobacco Campaign: Kwant Villagers Raze Gutkha Shops
  • 2 de-addiction centres face heat of police probe
  • Stage Shows Spread the Message Against Drugs
  • On The Anvil: Legal Age For Drinking And Purchasing Alcohol To Go Up From 21 To 25
  • Loneliness, Stress Driving Women to Hit the Bottle
  • Substance Abuse in Minors a Worry
  • Gathering urges help, compassion for addicts - Daily Star - Lebanon
  • Shisha 'as Bad as Ciggies'
  • Four Bad Habits Add 12 Years to your Age
  • Lethal Insomnia Drug Plays Havoc with Lives of Techies
  • Govt Stops Beer Sales in Department Stores
  • Genes influence smoking addiction: study - Sydney Morning Herald
  • American college students show drug-like addiction to gadgets and media - Geek.com
  • Study: Prescription Heroin Curbs Addiction, Crime - AHN | All Headline News
  • Canada's largest mental-health centre to ban smoking on property - Globe and Mail
  • Smoking will not make you slim - Sify
  • Stop making habit-forming drugs, govt asked - Times of India
  • Sidon seminar highlights dangers of drug use - Daily Star - Lebanon
  • Now's not the time to turn back on addiction treatment - The Dominion Post
  • From success to addiction to integrity - Hickory Daily Record
  • Non-Smokers Gain More Weight than Smokers
  • Smoking doesn't help in losing weight - Times of India
  • Record number of 'legal high' drugs emerge across EU - BBC News
  • Abbotsford addiction counsellors say drug dealers targeting young kids - News1130
  • Boozing May Lead to Premature Ageing
  • NIH unveils new opioid drug abuse therapy - UPI.com
  • Sex Addiction: Explanation or Excuse? 5 Common Traits - Huffington Post (blog)
  • The Devastating Combination of Psychiatric Illness and Drug Addiction - Psychology Today (blog)
  • Tracking drug addicts to identify, avoid hot spots - CNET
  • More preventive measures needed to curb drug abuse - Kuwait Times
  • Anti-Tobacco Law Enforcement Squads Soon
  • Three Held with 30 kg Ganja
  • Tanning addiction linked to drug abuse, anxiety - CTV.ca
  • New organization established in Azerbaijan to combat drug addiction - Trend News Agency
  • Will Conservative plans to overhaul heroin addiction treatment work? - The Guardian
  • Smoking likened to heroin addiction - BigPond News
  • Tobacco in Candy form Can Lead to Accidental Poisoning in Kids
  • Anti-Tobacco Campaign Launched
  • Man Held for Trying to Plant Drugs
  • Indoor Tanning Addiction Linked to Anxiety, Drug Abuse - WebMD
  • My 'Addiction' To Fighting Drugs - CNBC
  • Research Ushers in New Ray of Hope for Severe Alcoholic Hepatitis Sufferers
  • 'Drug addiction promotes crime, ruins health, lives of people' - Arab Times
  • Project Prevention: Unusual Approach to Dealing with Addiction - TestCountry.com (blog)
  • 'Just say no' approach ineffective at drug addiction prevention - Vancouver Sun
  • Drug addiction a constant battle for some young adults - Junior College
  • Medical rules lead to withdrawal of electronic quit-smoking aid - New Zealand Herald
  • Help for smokers trying to 'STOP' - Northumberland News
  • Depressed Adults Smoke More, Find it Difficult to Quit
  • Smoking ‘Counteracts Moderate Drinking Benefit on Stroke Risk’
  • 400 IMFL Bottles Seized, 1 Arrested
  • Madurai Village to Fine Tipplers
  • Smoking May Up Risk of Multiple Sclerosis
  • A Gene Test to Warn Smokers if They're Heading for Cancer
  • India to Frame Policy for Chewing Tobacco
  • Heroin Users on the Rise in Pearl City
  • Illicit Hooch Kills 9 in UP
  • Mumbai Woman Sold Drugs to Support Family
  • Smoking Lowers IQ
  • 2003 Drug Case: Court Convicts 7, Acquits 6
  • There's a Piggie in Your Ciggie!
  • Tobacco Vendors May Soon Need a Licence
  • 2,500kg Ganja Hidden Inside Oil Tanker Seized
  • Passive Smoking Dangerous for Kids
  • Tobacco Isn’t Cool
  • Liquor Makes Rs 12cr Flow into Government Coffers
  • Even Passive Smoking can Lead to Tuberculosis
  • Reforming Drug Treatment in the US: Two Steps Forward, One Step Back
  • For Indians, Alcohol is Killing
  • Tobacco Gender Bias
  • Overweight Drinkers Face Double Risk of Liver Damage
  • Cop Shields Hooch Seller
  • From June 1, Scarier Picture to Appear on Tobacco Packs
  • State has Highest Number of Registered Drug Addicts
  • Educate People About Illicit Iquor, High Court Tells Cops
  • Seven People Died After Consuming Spurious Liquor
  • Boozers 'Can't Blame Peer Pressure'
  • Study: Nearly One in Ten Gamers Shows Signs of Addiction
  • Desperate Mom Kills Drug-Addict Son
  • More Drug De-Addiction Centres Mooted
  • HC Notice to State, Centre
  • Quitting Smoking Improves Cardiac Health
  • Machines to Help Quit Smoking
  • Prepare Action Plan to Rehabilitate Drug Addicts: HC to Punjab, Haryana
  • It's a Long & Tough Road to Recovery
  • Illegal Drug Trade Scales New Heights
  • 50 Per Cent Drug Users in Nagaland are IDU: Report
  • Alcoholics Anonymous Meet on Sunday
Introducing Digital Practice for Doctors & Healthcare professionals

Sobriety Birthday

  • Sobriety birthday
  • Search Sobriety Birthday
Sobriety Birthday
National Award for Outstanding achievement by a Non-Professional - Tushar Sampat

Aarogya Network

aarogya.com aims to be India’s leading comprehensive health information portal. The site has sections, which cover almost all the medical specialties and give useful information on various diseases. To enhance its reach, the content is available in Indian languages too. We were the first health website to introduce online support groups. Addiction support and Epilepsy support are examples of some very active and vibrant communities.

» Click here to see all our support groups
Pune Aarogya
Digital Media Dedicated to Healthcare of Punekars

Subscribe Our Newsletter

Get health related new information.

Link to Aaraogya

aarogya logo

Email Code

Health Tools

  • Health Directory
  • Message Board
  • Health Calculators
  • Depression Screening Test

About Addictionsupport.aarogya.com

The We in Recovery is a project based on experience from the field. The project idea was conceived by Tushar Sampat of T-edge Solution Pvt. Ltd.

Read more...

Suggestions

This is YOUR site, so if you have suggestions or feedback on how we can improve it for you, please let us know! We do our best to keep up!

Read more...

User Comments

“My name is Paulette Conners and I just had to send you an email thanking you since one of the pages on your site was very helpful!”

  • Contact Us
  • Feedback
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Invite Your Friends
  • About Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Archive

© 2016 www.aarogya.com. All Rights Reserved.